Shingles VS Metal Roofs

Today, we are tackling one of the biggest questions in roofing: Metal roof or shingles?

Most homes in North America use asphalt shingles - they are familiar, cost-effective, and have been the standard here for decades. But here is a fun fact: in Europe, metal roofs are just as common as shingles are in Canada.

So let’s take a look at both options and see how they stack up.

Lifespan, Durability & Maintenance

Let’s be honest - shingles don’t age gracefully.

They typically last 12–20 years, depending on weather conditions and material quality. Wind, rain, sun, ice - you name it, they hate it. Ever noticed how the sun-facing side of your roof curls and flakes like a bad sunburn? That’s the shingles telling you they’ve had enough.

Maintenance with shingles is pretty standard after a strong wind or heavy rain. Anyone who remembers the windstorm in May 2022 knows how rough it can get (we received dozens of calls about shingles flying across lawns).

Metal roofs, on the other hand?

They’re in it for the long haul - 40 to 70 years, easily. No curling, cracking, or peeling. They’re like the tank of roofing materials.

And the way we install them? Using double wood strapping, anchored directly into your home’s framing. That roof isn’t going anywhere unless the entire house goes with it.

Wildlife Protection

Now here’s something people rarely think about—wildlife.

Shingles are like a welcome mat for raccoons and squirrels. Once those critters figure out how soft the roof is, they’ll chew right through to make themselves cozy in your attic.

We’ve literally seen raccoons stuck inside roof cavities, looking more surprised than the homeowners.

With a metal roof, animals hit a wall - literally. There’s nothing soft to chew, and for extra safety, we install metal mesh over ridge vents to keep things sealed and secure. Your attic stays your attic.

Curb Appeal & Style

Shingles may feel classic, but let’s be honest - metal roofs turn heads.

They come in a variety of colours and styles, some even mimicking the look of wood shakes, tile, or slate.

Want sleek and modern? We’ve got that. Want timeless and elegant? We’ve got that too.

And yes, your home’s value goes up too. Curb appeal = equity.

Energy Efficiency

Shingles absorb heat like a black T-shirt on a July afternoon. That means higher cooling costs in the summer.

Metal roofs? They reflect solar heat, and when paired with double wood strapping, create a ventilated gap that helps your attic stay cooler.

Homeowners can save up to 25% on cooling costs, and in winter, proper insulation underneath keeps things comfortable and efficient

Initial Cost vs. Long-Term Value

We’ll say it straight: Shingles cost less upfront.

But over 50 years, you’ll likely replace your shingle roof three times. Add in repairs, maintenance, and weather-related headaches, and it adds up fast.

Metal roofs cost more at the start, but they pay you back in peace of mind, energy savings, fewer repairs, and increased property value.

And if you do the math, the cost difference actually shrinks over time.

Environmental Impact

Asphalt shingles? Petroleum-based, non-recyclable, and destined for the landfill.

Metal roofing? Made from recycled materials and 100% recyclable at the end of its life. That’s the greener choice every time.

The Verdict

Sure, metal roofs cost a bit more in the beginning—but when it comes to lifespan, performance, safety, and peace of mind, they win across the board.

Especially if you're planning for retirement and don’t want to think about your roof again for the next 50+ years!